Constitutional Values Scorecard

Liberty Scorecard

Read the full Liberty Scorecard article

America’s Constitutional Scorecard

Measure how closely public figures, institutions, companies, schools, media organisations, cities, and other public entities align with the principles of the United States Constitution.

Evidence-based constitutional ratings supported by transparent methodology, documented sources, AI-assisted analysis, and human review.

Featured Essay · Cultural Custodian Overview

The Liberty Scorecard

A Bold New Scorecard to Restore America’s Constitutional Values

At a Glance

0–100 constitutional score
Evidence-based ratings
AI-assisted analysis
Human review
Public participation
Transparent methodology

It’s Friday night.

The kitchen table is covered with popcorn bowls. The kids are bouncing with excitement, begging for new TV shows to watch.

Mom and Dad stare at the laptop, exhausted at the week’s end.

They already pay for one subscription - and they’re sick of Netflix slipping the same identity lessons and gender ideology into their living room that is being force-fed to their children at school.

Now they face this decision helplessly: Hulu... or Paramount+?

One more subscription. One more chance to hand their family over to the very culture war they want to escape.

Then, in a moment of pure frustration, they search for answers - and discover something that stops them cold.

This is more than a family’s Friday-night dilemma. It’s the same question that drove Xavier King in Life in Woke America - what’s a person to do when the institutions and big business turn on law-abiding citizens, including their children? Written after the author left the Democratic Party, this is what sparked the founding of the Liberty Scorecard.

The Liberty Scorecard

America’s bold “constitutional culture scorecard” - a clear, reasonable, numeric rating system that measures how reliably people, cities, companies, schools, media outlets, and cultural products stack up against the U.S. Constitution’s principles and the Bill of Rights.

One glance at the Liberty Scorecard changes everything:

Original Liberty Score comparison showing Hulu at 42 and Paramount Plus at 58

The numbers hit like a thunderclap. Hulu is deeply infected with Disney’s woke agenda, making its casting inauthentic and contrived, and its stories vapid propaganda. The other is still not what it used to be - entertainment that portrays a world we know or share. The score, 58, immediately signals that things are improving at Paramount - more to the liking of Mom and Dad.

For the first time, this family - and millions like them - finally have powerful weapons for the raging culture war. Every individual can be a custodian of the conservative values held dear by the U.S. Constitution.Joel Rakow
Custodians of Constitutional Values and America 250 graphic from the original article

At the Core of the Scorecard

The Liberty Scorecard score estimates how well the values of any entity align with the U.S. Constitution and the Bill of Rights, especially:

  • Individual liberty and agency (1st, 2nd, 4th, 5th, 9th, and 10th Amendments) - not groups.
  • Equal protection under the law - no group-based preferences or quotas (5th and 14th Amendments).
  • Rule of law, due process, and limited government - rejection of corruption and selective enforcement.
  • Free speech, free press, and free exercise of religion - viewpoint diversity without compelled speech or viewpoint discrimination.
  • Pursuit of happiness and ordered liberty - merit, family, self-reliance, and cultural stewardship that strengthen the republic.

DEI/ESG policies are treated as evidence of misalignment when they impose race/gender/identity preferences, compelled speech, or political litmus tests that restrain a citizen’s free agency.

Corruption - whether bribery, nepotism, conflicts of interest, or misuse of power - receives the same explicit downgrade as other threats to the constitutional order.

Scores and Tiers

The scoring is a single numeric value between 0 and 100, and it has clear tiers:

90-100Strong constitutional alignment (“Truth in Culture” / high Liberty)
70-89Mostly aligns, with minor deviations
40-69Mixed or neutral
20-39Significant opposition to constitutional norms, including identity politics, weak election integrity and border management, and material corruption
0-19Active subversion of constitutional norms

These scores and tiers demonstrate the range, or spectrum - from strong constitutional alignment to active opposition - and give users a level of immediacy and precision that is valuable.

  • Higher score: stronger alignment with individual liberty, merit, family values, traditional American culture, and minimal forced identity politics/DEI/ESG agendas.
  • Lower score: heavier emphasis on DEI quotas/preferences, ESG-driven identity politics, or agenda-over-merit in storytelling, governance, education, and other elements of our culture.

How the Scorecard Works

The Liberty Scorecard is a living platform that delivers transparent 0-100 Liberty Scores for any person, city, company, school, media outlet, or cultural product. It provides a curated score and a crowd-powered score. The two scores appear prominently and visually paired with the entity being assessed.

Two Scores Side by Side

Evidence-led

Liberty Curated Score

Produced by the Liberty Scorecard team using publicly available documents - policies, ESG/DEI reports, content, voting records, official statements, donor affiliations, court records, and related material.

Community-led

User-Community Score

Aggregated from verified users whose ratings are based on their personal combination of evidence, experience, and perception. User ratings appear separately, giving a fuller picture of real-world sentiment.

The Liberty Scorecard carries power and influence when directed at enemies of our constitutional culture. The original overview illustrates the paired scores across cities, the press, public figures, entertainment, colleges and universities, and libraries.

Cities

Original cities comparison showing Liberty Scores for New York City and Memphis, Tennessee

The Press

Original press comparison showing Liberty Scores for the Los Angeles Times and The Epoch Times

Public Figures

Original public figures comparison showing Liberty Scores for Gavin Newsom and Scott Bessent

Entertainment

Original entertainment comparison showing Liberty Scores for Dead End: Paranormal Park and Yellowstone

College & University Libraries

Original college and university libraries comparison showing Liberty Scores for UCLA and Hillsdale College
Evidence and analytical judgment: Facts and events should be supported by accessible sources. A Liberty Score represents application of the methodology to that evidence and is an analytical assessment—not an objective scientific measurement or legal determination. Legacy examples below require source-by-source editorial verification before being treated as current published ratings. Read the methodology.

Justification for Curated Ratings

The evidence-based ratings are reasonable, if not perfect or irrefutable. They are suitable, we believe, for a great many of life’s decisions. Here are examples of how the curated ratings of four of the entities presented above are justified. You be the judge of their validity:

Scott Bessent (U.S. Treasury Secretary): 81/100

Key evidence: Trump administration Treasury Secretary (confirmed 2025). Actively implements “America First” economic policies focused on merit, tariffs, energy independence (“all-of-the-above” including fossil fuels), and rolling back federal DEI programs. Publicly criticized World Bank/IMF and CFPB for “mission creep” into climate, gender, and social/DEI issues, stating they “impinge on monetary credibility.” Opposes elite-driven climate and identity mandates in favor of practical prosperity and liberty-focused governance.

Why this score: Strong alignment with merit-based economics and pushback against institutional wokeness. (Personal background as an openly gay man is noted in media but does not factor into the policy/actions-based framework.)

Gavin Newsom (Governor of California): 28/100

Key evidence: Long track record embedding DEI/equity into state government (Racial Equity Commission, equity analysis required in all budgets and policies). Signed landmark ESG/climate disclosure laws (SB 253, SB 261) forcing major companies to report emissions and climate risks. Aggressive clean-energy mandates, cap-and-trade extensions, environmental justice initiatives, and sanctuary-state policies. Continued heavy promotion of “equity” frameworks even amid national rollbacks.

Why this score: Textbook high-woke state-level governance prioritizing identity/equity/ESG over pure merit and individual liberty (very close to NYC’s 34).

Yellowstone (TV series, created by Taylor Sheridan): 88/100

Key evidence: Focuses on story-first storytelling centered on family values, land, individual strength, merit, and traditional Western/American themes. Minimal forced identity lectures; often critiques corporate greed, environmental activists, California elites, and gentrification without DEI-style quotas or agenda pauses. Sheridan’s broader work (and the show’s cultural reputation) is widely viewed as anti-woke or “conservative-leaning” by audiences and critics alike - emphasizing real heroes and universal themes over identity politics.

Why this score: One of the strongest cultural examples of “Worth It” entertainment (higher than Epoch Times’ 82 because it reaches massive mainstream audiences with unapologetic traditional values).

Dead End: Paranormal Park (Netflix animated series, 2022): 18/100

Key evidence: Centers explicitly on a gay transgender boy protagonist (Barney) and his journey of identity, family rejection/acceptance, and queer romance. Heavy, overt LGBTQ+ representation and transgender themes are core to the plot and marketing (voiced by a trans actor; praised by reviewers for “groundbreaking” trans visibility aimed at youth). Prioritizes identity politics and inclusion messaging over traditional storytelling or universal themes.

Why this score: Extremely high-woke kids’ content that places agenda and identity front-and-center (lower than the LA Times’ 26 due to its explicit focus on gender ideology for a younger audience).

User Participation

Planned feature: The Liberty Scorecard application concept may eventually allow people to create accounts, suggest entities, and submit evidence-informed community ratings. These functions are not currently represented as operational on this public website.

Any future participation model should distinguish curated editorial scores from community sentiment and should publish clear moderation, correction, privacy, and anti-abuse standards before launch.

Security Controls

Proposed model: Future community functionality may use privacy-conscious anti-abuse and identity-verification mechanisms designed to discourage bots, duplicate accounts, and coordinated manipulation.

The public website does not collect fingerprints, iris or eye scans, Social Security information, or biometric identity data for Liberty Scorecard participation. Any future verification system would require a properly engineered third-party architecture, data-minimization review, security testing, and legal/privacy approval before implementation.

Unique in a Strong Class of Others

The concept of scoring “liberty” or constitutional alignment is not new. For decades, respected think tanks and advocacy groups have published rigorous numerical rating systems to measure alignment with the principles of individual liberty, the rule of law, limited government, and free markets - core elements of the U.S. Constitution and the Bill of Rights. Cato Institute and Freedom House are two examples, with others identified in the original overview.

Yet these established indices fail to meet the needs of today’s polarized society. For example:

  • They focus almost exclusively on countries, states, or politicians - rarely on cities, companies, media, education, art, or entertainment.
  • None directly counter today’s scoring regimes for DEI (Diversity, Equity, Inclusion) or ESG (Environment, Social, Governance) that dominate corporate America and culture today.
  • None explicitly frame themselves as a tool for measuring alignment between everyday American life and the U.S. Constitution and Bill of Rights.

Cultural Extension for Today’s Needs

The Liberty Scorecard is the natural cultural extension of these respected precedents. It applies the same rigorous, numeric, evidence-based approach - but extends it across America’s cultural landscape (e.g., news outlets, elections, law enforcement, immigration, commerce, education, K-University, art and entertainment). It treats corruption, woke ideology, and lawlessness as direct threats to constitutional order - exactly as America’s Founders would have understood.

The Liberty Scorecard is designed to be the modern, comprehensive constitutional culture scorecard America has been missing: the counterpunch to the outside influences we see undermining the American way of life. Its “Truth in Culture” credo hones it into sharpened iron, empowering citizens as faithful custodians of liberty.

With America’s culture under sustained attack, Americans need more than words. They need a weapon. The Liberty Scorecard is that sharpened iron - a blade forged in the fire of constitutional principle.Joel Rakow

With America’s culture under sustained attack - news media is turned against the people, city governments embrace socialism, elections grow untrustworthy, and laws are enacted to prevent investigations into corruption festering in plain sight - Americans need more than words. They need a weapon. The Liberty Scorecard is that sharpened iron - a blade forged in the fire of constitutional principle. It cuts cleanly through the fog of woke ideology and blatant lawlessness with an inescapable score.

It exposes what was never meant to serve our democratic republic, and rewards what has worked for 250 years of world-beating excellence: individual liberty, merit, equal protection, rule of law, and ordered freedom. The Liberty Scorecard is much more than just another rating system. Every family, every parent, every citizen can now become a Custodian of Constitutional Values.

This novel and the Liberty Scorecard are like fraternal twins. The story dramatizes what low Liberty scores look like in today’s culture war. The Liberty Scorecard is the weapon for conservative people to fight and to win that war.

Read the novel that inspired it. Celebrate the 250th year of the country with more bold purpose. Use the Liberty Scorecard to protect your family’s future.

The Time Has Come

Visit www.LifeInWokeAmerica.com today and join the battle. Become a verified user. Add entities. Submit your ratings. Share the scores far and wide.

Voice yourself on X @inWokeAmerica.

The time has come to wield our sharpened iron - and reclaim the constitutional culture that built the greatest nation in history.

- Joel Rakow, Ed.D., author of Life in Woke America: A Family’s Story of Truth and Betrayal Under Fire

About the Creator

Joel Rakow, Ed.D., author of Life in Woke America, created the Liberty Scorecard concept.

Read Joel Rakow’s complete biography.

The Book

The novel is the human story of institutions and big business turning against law-abiding citizens and their families.

The Scorecard

A clear, evidence-based AI utility for assessing constitutional alignment in public life.

The Custodians

A community program for scholars, thought leaders, and citizens who defend constitutional principles.

The novel is the foundation — the raw, human story of what happens when institutions and big business turn against law-abiding citizens and their families.

The Liberty Scorecard is the means — America’s bold new 0–100 constitutional culture scorecard. It equips every citizen with a clear, evidence-based AI-utility to assess alignment between the Constitution and the people, institutions, and companies that shape American society.

The Custodians Program

Every family, every parent, every citizen can now easily align with constitutional values by rating cities, companies, media, schools, and public figures — and hold those products of our society accountable.

We launched with 14 Founding Custodians of Constitutional Values drawn from 2,400+ engaged followers on X @inWokeAmerica where this list can be found.

We invite distinguished scholars and thought leaders to serve as Emeritus Custodians or Academic Advisors. This is a low-time-commitment, high-impact role. It recognizes your scholarship and public defense of constitutional principles, classical liberal education, and viewpoint diversity. Your name and photo would appear among the Custodians, amplifying your work to a growing audience of parents, voters, and cultural stewards who are hungry for rigorous, evidence-based tools.

The Liberty Scorecard is the sharpened iron America has been waiting for.

Will you join us as an Emeritus Custodian?

We would be honored to schedule a brief 10–15 minute call at your convenience to discuss how to make this opportunity work best for you.

Schedule a Brief Conversation

Join the Liberty Scorecard Updates List

Get Liberty Scorecard Updates

This is the only page on the site with email capture. Subscribe here for Liberty Scorecard scorecards, Custodians Program updates, and constitutional values resources.

Patriot Community

Get Chapter 1 Free + Liberty Scorecard Updates

Join the Life in Woke America community and receive Chapter 1 free, Liberty Scorecard scorecards, launch updates, and exclusive content from Joel Rakow.

Your subscription could not be saved. Please try again.
Thank you for joining the Life in Woke America Community. Watch your inbox for Chapter 1, Liberty Scorecard updates, and future announcements from Joel Rakow.

Get Chapter 1 Free + Liberty Scorecard Updates

Join the Life in Woke America community and receive Chapter 1 free, Liberty Scorecard scorecards, launch updates, and exclusive content from Joel Rakow.